Feb. 2 Daily Question

The narrative of Jacob and Esau carries forward Genesis’ presentation of what it means to be God’s elect. As with Abraham and Isaac, we should expect some sort of “death” and “resurrection,” much as we saw in the Aqedah. To see how that pattern emerges in the life of Jacob, who himself will undergo a kind of death and rebirth, attend to what it is that Jacob takes in the story and what it is he eventually receives. (A common theme, no?) The center, of course, is his relationship with Esau and through Esau, with God. To ready ourselves for lecture, please consider the scene of Jacob’s wrestling and answer two simple questions. Who wins, really? And who is his opponent?

Much like the stories we have seen before of brotherly rivalry and greed, the same is seen with Jacob and Esau. Jacob, as a result of how he was born, lacked the title of first born, and was second to Esau as a favorite in his father’s eyes. For selfish reasons and desires of the great fortune that replacing Isaac will entail, Jacob, with his own hands, attempts to secure these by using trickery and deceit. He gets Esau’s birthright and tricks his father into giving him the blessing that was reserved for Esau, but strangely, and unlike what has been seen previously in Genesis, what Jacob took, he eventually also kept. He becomes entrusted to continuing the patriarchal promise God made to Abraham and his father, despite the means he took to arrive there, but it came at the cost of unresolved conflict with his brother, whose resolution forms the context of a wrestle between Jacob, and what is believed to be an angel. On a more metaphorical level, however, there is reason to believe that the battle could actually be an internal one, that of Jacob with his fears and everything he had to address with coming back. It is hard to say if a definitive winner exists, because while no man won, the figure made a last ditch effort and grabbed Jacob’s thigh. Even though at the end, Jacob was the one who resulted with an injury, I believe that he ended up winning the skirmish, because aside from physical damage, he emerged with a new name– one resembling God–, a blessing, and perhaps something that would resemble the resolution of his conflict with Esau.

2 thoughts on “Feb. 2 Daily Question”

  1. I really like the subtle reference to Cain and Able – brotherly spite seems to be a common theme in Genesis. I definitely agree that the battle and the stranger are ambiguous and up to interpretation, whether it is God himself, an angel, or a metaphorical fight between Jacob and his consciousness. Personally, I believe that winner is really judged by intent, so without a clear intent, it’s hard for me to determine which ones was which. However, I do agree that Jacob did benefit ultimately.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free